13 Reasons Why I liked 13 Reasons Why
Before I start writing this blog I want to lay out some WARNINGS:
* if you have not seen the show, their might be clues or hints to some spoilers. I would still encourage you to watch the series, or read the book, as long as you are old enough to handle mature content. Please let your parents know if you are watching this.
* some of the things I am going to share are sensitive, raw, real. I want to do my best to share my thoughts while also giving dignity and honor to myself, other people and families who have had to handle these situations.
* I am not a psychologist or counselor. These words are my opinion. I am not here to make people feel good about these topics, but expose some truths - maybe ask some tough questions, help us all grow through challenges. But grow together, with love. This is a very controversial topic.
* as mentioned, these are my opinions. I tend to have the emotional range of a teaspoon. Please do not layer extra emotion, or perceive false emotion that is not there. AKA, don't "read between the lines"
****
A few weeks ago my junior high students started talking about a show on Netflix called 13 Reasons Why. That night I went home, and sure enough, I started seeing several people posts about the show (some without even viewing it). I started to do research and realized I needed to watch this. Now, that sounds really silly that there was a need to watch a TV show; but I wanted to know what my students (12-14 year old kiddos) are watching and talking about. I also shared some information with my school counselor so she too could be aware. Later that week, Thursday night, I stayed up incredibly late and watched 4....FOUR....hour long episodes. Within a week, I completed the season (in a week?!... what else am I going to do at night when my husband is writing papers for his classes?). This past week I have had students share that they enjoyed the show, that dramas are their favorite type of shows. So to some, the material is already desensitized, and they see it for a show, not a reason or an instructional film.
I tend to think differently than my peers and others, everyone's stories shape them. I tend to play devil's advocate in hopes to help others, including myself, see multiple perspectives. As I write this, I am also challenging my own thoughts and beliefs and want to encourage you to ask me more questions to help me grow as well. Challenging the culture to challenge myself. May is mental health awareness month. Go to this site to watch a video on why 13 reasons can be an useful tool.
It's okay to disagree.
It's not okay to ignore the problem.
13 Reasons Why I liked 13 Reasons Why:
1) The show was written like a mystery. You know, in the very beginning that the main character, Hannah, did kill herself. But as the journey continues, and you flash back and forth between Hannah's stories and other's, you start getting a deeper picture of this school's reality. Over all, the show was well written; and I'm interested in the next season as well as reading the book.
2) Tony and his tapes. Just Tony. He is one of the main characters. At first you are trying to figure out his purpose, or how he's connected. The idea of using tapes, a media source that is no longer readily available, makes me secretly enjoy the retro-ness of the tapes. Tony appears to be the kid, with his head on straight, that has all the answers, but he too, is struggling with the grief and loss of Hannah and personal issues of his own. Tony started off as my favorite character, but my heart swelled with love and compassion for all of them.
3) A call to parents. I believe if you watch the entire season, this show is a cry from society's youth. The cry of "HELP" is now taking light from media. Mental illness is a serious issue, and does attack all age groups. However, I feel as if it is rapidly effecting our youth. Internet and cell phones have enabled people to hurt others more, faster, and without repercussions. The very first episode you get to experience how rumors can destroy a person's reputation and become the starting line for other events. As a parent, are you helping your child navigate this broken world? Are you helping other children who may not have caring parents navigate this world? Because chances are if you are reading this, you are a caring parent. Together, we can raise up a generation who know what love is and how to cope and manage trauma and how to use media tools more effectively. Please go here if you are in need of more guidance on suicide prevention.
4) Parental response. I enjoyed how the show included a third story line of how the parents were dealing with their daughter's choice. Although some articles written believe that this show "romanticizes" the idea of suicide, I think that some would see the hurt that it caused for their family. The accuracy of parents suing the school is something that does happen regularly. My question, and I have not been in their shoes, does suing the school for hundred-thousands of dollars, help in the grief process? Will they later change their mind as Hannah's tapes are played for them? Did they realize that she committed suicide by using something that she got from their store?
5) The show is raw. The producers and writers did an excellent job not sugar coating the seriousness of the issue. From suicide, to teen drinking, abuse, rumors, porn, and everything in between, every scene was written with awareness. For those who watched and believe that it was too much; I can agree that not all social circles are as broken as this circle of peers. But, if you believe that these issues are not happening to OUR youth, I hate to tell you, but you are being blinded. Some of these characters stories are stories from my own 7th grade students. Ignorance and ignoring there is a problem, will not help these students and our next generation.
6) Gun control. Now, this is a bit odd, for Hannah did not use a gun in her act of suicide. What I am talking about as far as guns is the ease that the students have access to them. From harming themselves to others, guns were not in trained hands. I am not, let me repeat, I am not advocating for gun control. Guns are a tool that needs to be taught how to use correctly. I think that this issue will be addressed more in the second season.
7) The variety of students. I enjoyed how the students had a variety of roles in the school. From football players, to edgy coffee baristas, cheerleaders, poetry writers, school yearbook photographer, student body president, the school's outcast, and others. I liked this because it helps us have a better grasp to the idea that no group of adolescents is safe from these tough issues. That from the outside, young teens might appear to have the "best life" but in reality they are suffering and hurting as well. Every character was a person I could relate to on a variety of levels.
8) The emotional roller coaster. As I mentioned, I am not much of an emotional person. I hurt and empathize for people but as I have grown and changed from my own experiences I have learned to think through situations. However, this show had me all over the place. I was a wreck. The characters did a great job acting and portraying the real emotion throughout the scenes. As I mentioned in number 7, the characters are real. For me, I had to turn my eyes away, or pause the show, for it brought up a lot of history and past for myself to reprocess. You start off being angry at some characters for their actions, but as their story unfolds your heart just opens up and you truly fall in love with them. As a parent and teacher, I just wanted to give them all hugs and help them. I cried for them, with them, and with our young people going through these stories in real life.
9) Every choice you make effects someone. Although some of the situations Hannah was put through might have seemed small to some, and that other teens might have handled differently or even better. It was the culmination of the events that hurt her deepest. Some watchers are upset at Hannah, "how rude for her to blame other people for a selfish choice, how can she blame others?" The tapes were not so much a blame, but her getting her voice out there. Letting her classmates, teachers, counselors and parents know that she is hurting because of others. Every interaction you have with a person can change the path on which they are traveling. The counselor at the school was maybe not the most trained counselor, and although she was clearly in need of help, as I sat watching him listen to his own tape, hearing his own faults, I started questioning my own. Which of my students is secretly hurting? Which of my students thought I was being too harsh on them? Which of my students truly needs help? It really helped remind me that I need to be more aware of how I treat others - more so than I do now. We all have a story. The parents were effected deeply, but they too had their role within Hannah's story. Does this make what Hannah did right? For people who do not think they have a way out of their emotions, or can't see past the deepness of the black pit they are in, the option of taking their own lives is what they think is their only option. Helping students and all adults to be better aware that there is help available, and that they are not alone, is a focus we should be pulling from this show.
10) No religious affiliation. As a Christian it is hard for me to say that I am glad that there was not any religions mentioned. Religion would have been a distraction for the topics presented. If one religion was mentioned and not another, feelings would have been hurt, or worse, the religion could be blamed for the events of Hannah's death. Honestly, by not having the layer of religion take place, it enables the religious lens to be removed, giving sight to the fact that all creeds and beliefs are vulnerable to these topics and situations.
11) Every issue. Every. Single. One. 13 Reasons Why was able to write a serious series over pretty much every issue happening in our world today. From rumors, cyber bulling, porn, gun safety, harassment, prejudice, drinking, drugs, young sex, rape, abuse on every level, financial difficulties, gay relationships, cutting.......the show brings up every thing. The show did not leave something unaddressed. As a christian parent it does scare me from time to time the world in which our children are living and growing up in. Sadly, the culture we are experiencing is one that has been around since the fall took place in the garden. These issues are real. If you have not experienced these issues yourself, you know people who have. Although this is a reason I continued to watch the show, it is also breaks my heart deeply.
12) An open door for difficult conversations. Before this show, how many of these topics were addressed, thought about, or handled in your own home? How many of us have experienced any of this? How many people had no idea that this happened? The show is full of awareness towards these sensitive issues, it also has the potential to open doors for young people to open up and start telling their stories. I loved, loved, loved the last episode when Jessica realizes that she is not doing well. That she can no longer go down this path by her self, pushing everyone away. That she is not alone. She starts to tell her story. We all have a story. But are we all willing to listen?
13) The commentary. There is an "episode" that has the actors, writers, producers, psychologist and others discussing why they were apart of this show and what their hopes of the show are. I encourage you, if you are unsure if you want to watch this show, to watch the commentary first. Although it might give away spoilers to how everything turns out, I think it helps to hear the hearts of the people who put the show together. They want truth to be exposed, their own site is a link for people to get help.
****
As one would start with a warning, I too am going to end with DISCLAIMERS:* please do not watch the show if you are currently feeling as if the world is against you, that you are alone. You are not alone. There are people who do care. If you feel that you can not share what is going on, for your own safety, try to remember your safety is one of the biggest reasons TO share. The professional you get help from will make sure to do everything possible to keep you safe. Please talk to a trusted adult at school, at the top is a link for a hotline that gives full confidentiality and here is another source. YOU ARE LOVED.
* watch the show, if you can, it does have moments that are so real you have to look away. Being able to pause this show and digest it in pieces, was so incredibly helpful. If you are under the age of 18 please share with your parents that you are watching or have watched 13 reasons, or better yet ask them to watch with you.
* love people. LOVE PEOPLE. If we could all show more compassion for the beautiful differences in our world and come to understanding that everyone has a story; that is when we might realize that we are not all so different. Love people.
Let me know your thoughts!
If you ever want to or need to talk, please let me know.
I love swapping stories.
Tiffany has watched most of the episodes. Devon has started watching. Their mom watched some to see if it's ok to let them continue. After reading this, I will watch so the lines of communication with my grandkids will be available. Thanks for posting this.
ReplyDeleteI don't know your story, but it will totally help with communication with grandkids - as long as we approach the truth with love.
DeleteThanks for sharing your review about this show! I haven't seen it but I'm not sure that I would. I think it would tough to handle since I've been through some of these issues with my circle of friends. I'm so glad for your in depth review!
ReplyDeleteI too have some very close connections to the stories in the show. However, although it was tough at parts, I am glad I watched. It almost validated what I felt when things happened or how they were handled with my friends and family. However, I am also distant enough from my past.
DeleteThanks for reading!
I loved the show and I agree with your entire post!!! Very well thought out and written! I have seen so many posts by people who think the show romanticizes suicide, so it was really refreshing to read a post by someone who sees and understands that the show is a valuable teaching tool to help make people more aware of how their actions can affect others.
ReplyDeleteThank you for reading. I felt the same way. I even had friends "bashing" the show without even watching it. Is it adult - absolutely.
DeleteThank you for sharing your point of view on the series. I have heard so much negativity surrounding this show so it was good to read more insight from someone that has watched it!
ReplyDeleteAppreciate you taking time to read. You nailed it on the head - watched it. :)
DeleteGrace has not watched and has no interest. We have discussed most of the issues that are in the show. Before this show came out. I have offered to re watch it with her and she has declined. I too felt very connected on so many levels with these students. I felt as tho the counsler had really dropped the ball all she wanted was someone to listen. And so that he didnt loose his job he even tore out the page in the calender from where her visit was documented. I believe her parents will feel remorse after they listen for their law suit, but she was bullied she tried to get help and i feel like school staff including family and friends should have seen that change in hannah. I too fell in love with every character at some point with the exception of Bryce. Maybe having a book club where we meet 1x a week and read a chapter at a time and discuss how to better help our kids their friends and our community. I would totally be down with that. If grace wanted to watch she knows all she has to do is ask and i would watch it with her. She is not one to usually give into popularity or peer pressure to watch or buy something because everyone else does or has it. We have discussed this with her and are thankful everyday for her decision to be just grace because god made only one of her to be just the way she is. :) let me know if you start something up im in.
ReplyDeleteWhat a great idea! I might have to get together with the counselor on that one. Sadly there is a lot of "red tape" or protocol I have to adhere by as a teacher, not a trained counselor. But I think opening up healthy dialogue within our school might be a refreshing change.
DeleteI have not read the book - does it follow like the tapes?
Might be a good summer project too?
And you can do one too :)
I love that Gracd is Grace! It always worries me the ones, at such a young age, believe popularity is so important. I have trouble sometimes figuring out who is popular these days. Ones I think are, sometimes aren't and vice Versa. Grace is popular for she is kind to kids. She is also mature, I will give her "looks" when other kids are being kids. She gets it. Be a proud momma!